Honest review of Death Comes for the Archbishop

by Willa Cather (Author)

Updated at: 18/02/2025

Willa Cather's Death Comes for the Archbishop isn't a tale of dramatic demise, but a vibrant chronicle of a life fully lived. The novel follows Archbishop Jean Marie Latour, not through a single pivotal event, but across the expansive arc of his career in the American Southwest. Beginning with a serene scene—a dinner among Cardinals in Rome—the narrative unfolds, eschewing conventional climaxes for a gentler, more profound exploration of faith, dedication, and the shaping of a landscape, both physical and spiritual. Cather masterfully depicts the Archbishop's enduring legacy, built not on fleeting triumphs, but on the slow, steady work of a lifetime dedicated to service.

4.4 / 3,720 ratings

Review Death Comes for the Archbishop

Death Comes for the Archbishop surprised me. Going in, I expected a straightforward historical novel, perhaps a bit dry given the subject matter: the establishment of the Catholic Church in the American Southwest. While the historical setting is richly detailed and undeniably captivating—Cather’s descriptions of the New Mexican landscape are simply breathtaking, painting vivid pictures of rugged beauty and harsh realities—the book is far more nuanced than I anticipated.

It's not a plot-driven narrative in the traditional sense. There isn't a dramatic climax or a thrilling chase. Instead, it’s a quiet, contemplative journey, following Archbishop Latour’s life as he builds a diocese from the ground up. The story unfolds slowly, deliberately, much like the slow growth of a cathedral or the gradual transformation of a desolate land. This measured pace, initially something I perceived as slow, eventually became one of the book's greatest strengths. It allowed for a deep immersion into the characters and their world.

The relationship between Archbishop Latour and Father Vaillant is a cornerstone of the novel. Their contrasting personalities and approaches to their mission provide a fascinating dynamic. It’s a testament to the power of friendship, loyalty, and shared purpose, even amidst immense challenges. Cather expertly portrays their bond, highlighting not only their differences but also their deep mutual respect and affection. Their friendship, in fact, is almost as compelling a narrative thread as the Archbishop’s own life journey.

Beyond the central characters, Cather beautifully depicts the diverse population of New Mexico at the time – the Native Americans, the Mexicans, and the European settlers, each with their own distinct cultures and beliefs. The novel is subtly critical of the impact of colonization and the clash between cultures, but it's never preachy or judgmental. Instead, it offers a nuanced portrayal of a time of significant change and adaptation. It's a world where faith, resilience, and the power of human connection are tested—and often prevail—against the backdrop of an awe-inspiring and sometimes unforgiving landscape.

The title, "Death Comes for the Archbishop," initially suggests a focus on the Archbishop’s demise. While his death is the book's final chapter, the story isn’t about the act of dying but rather the life lived before it. It's a celebration of a life dedicated to service, perseverance, and the building of something lasting and meaningful. The novel leaves a lingering sense of quiet satisfaction—a feeling of witnessing a life well-lived, a legacy established, and the enduring impact of one man's devotion. It's a reflection on mortality, yes, but one that ultimately affirms the value of a life spent building bridges across cultures, enduring hardship, and fostering deep and lasting connections. I found it both beautifully written and profoundly moving. It's a book that stays with you long after you've finished reading it.

See more: Honest review of Recompense: A King's Reckoning